Reba McEntire aced her ACM Awards hosting duties on Sunday night. The country icon cracked jokes, had an epic performance with Kelly Clarkson and, like any truly talented award show host, had an impressive number of outfit changes. And one of the best style swaps of them all was when she changed into a red dress which she originally wore in 1993!

Rtgwinn/mediapunch/REX/Shutterstock; Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP/REX/Shutterstock

Rtgwinn/mediapunch/REX/Shutterstock; Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP/REX/Shutterstock

McEntire dug out a red, “very revealing” turtleneck dress with flared sleeves and jeweled bodice to perform her 1993 hit, “Does He Love You” alongside her daughter-in-law, Clarkson.

She last wore the dress during the 1993 CMA Awards and told PEOPLE it ended up being one of her favorite looks of the night.

“I really liked the red dress from the ’90s,” McEntire tells PEOPLE. “It was like seeing an old friend again. When Sandi Spika made that dress for me, I felt like Cinderella. I wore it to the CMA Awards 25 years ago when singing ‘Does He Love You’ with Linda Davis. Sandi Spika Borchetta, who’d been touring with me and designing my clothes for years, designed it.”

Want to know more about her impressive nine outfit changes and how she chose each look? PEOPLE Style has an exclusive photo diary straight from Reba and her team here.